Ten Thoughts on Hosting Thanksgiving

By Posted in - Food on November 19th, 2014 30 Comments


Last week the Relevant Podcast team asked me to share ten Thanksgiving tips on the podcast…and just so you have the full picture, that means a text comes from Cameron, about an hour before we record, while I’m up to my eyeballs in backpack-packing, toast-toasting and toddler wrangling–“Hey, Chad and I have an idea.  Call me.” To which I reply, “Let me get the boys to school. And drink my coffee. Will call asap.” And then when I do call, they tell me they’ve recorded a jingle, asked Jesse to work up some funny questions…and here’s the thing: all they need from me are a few Thanksgiving tips. Ha!

Basically, my involvement in the podcast is just exactly like the rest of my life: extremely last minute, occasionally stressful because of it, but more often really, really fun.

But I actually was all set for the Thanksgiving tips, because just the night before, our Cooking Club had our Thanksgiving dinner. It was delicious and fun and totally got me in the Thanksgiving spirit. This year we’ve hit the Thanksgiving jackpot: we’re going to the lake with my family for Thanksgiving with my grandparents, then on Friday night we’re hosting a houseful for Friendsgiving, and on Sunday we’re having a Chinese takeout feast at my in-laws, because at that point, the thinking is that everyone will have been eating nothing but stuffing and pumpkin pie for days, and egg rolls will be a welcome change. I love egg rolls, but I do think I could eat stuffing for a very, very long time and never tire of it. But I digress.

Ten Thoughts for Hosting Thanksgiving

1.  Remember: it’s about the gathering, not about the food. This is the most important thing to keep in mind. I know Thanksgiving might be the most food-driven of all holidays, but the people are always more important than the food. The gathering is what’s significant…that’s what you remind yourself when the turkey’s taking forever or the stuffing’s dry. And it’s TRUE.

2. Stay classic. This is not the holiday to flout tradition. People become quite cranky if you don’t have, say, cranberry sauce or French fried onions on top of the green bean casserole. This is not the time to surprise people with a wild South-of-the-Border feast, or a beautiful spread of sushi. I have made this mistake, and people were not happy.

3. Ask for help. No one, and I repeat, no one, should cook a Thanksgiving meal alone. Ask each guest to bring something, and invite a few people over to help set the table, prep veggies, etc. It’s always more fun together, and people like to be included in the process. Feel free to be specific about what to bring, and give people clear tasks when they ask how they can help.

4. Invite people into meaningful conversation. If you’re not intentional, a whole day with family and friends can go by without a focused moment or conversation. It’s especially easy to let it pass because you’re stressed about all the food prep. Plan ahead–a question on the back of every placecard, or conversation cards scattered on the table. If you’re hosting, take the opportunity to invite deeper connection around your table. Feel free to be quite directive about it–it feels awkward in the moment, sometimes, but I find that people are always thankful afterward. People want to connect deeply, but it often takes one person to create an environment that allows it.

5. Simple table idea: cover table with butcher paper or kraft paper, and then decorate it with words and pictures–and if kids can do this, all the better. Set jars filled with colored pencils all over the table, so that people can doodle and add to the decorations. Sometimes people get really stressed out at big holidays, feeling like they have to have some spectacular tablescape–cornucopias! Gourds! A woodland village! If that’s your jam, go for it, definitely. But if that makes you feel tremendously overwhelmed, don’t worry about it. Butcher paper, pencils–voila! Simple and fun, and a great way to get kids involved.

6. No scented candles. This is an all-the-time hosting thing. Candles are lovely–the more, the better…but no scented candles to get all mixed up with the great food smells. There is nothing worse than candy-cane candle smell times stuffing smell.

7. Don’t go overboard on hors d’oeuvres. People are serious about Thanksgiving food, and most of them are practicing some sort of complex strategy for how to consume a staggering amount of both turkey and pie. You can’t win with lots of appetizers–if you have tons, and people eat them all, then they’ll be angry with you for filling up their stomachs, stealing their pie space. But if they don’t touch them, practicing their strategy, then you’ll feel bad about all the time you spent wrapping pigs in their yummy little blankets.

8. Spatchcock your turkey. I know. I know. It sounds illegal. But it’s a serious time-and-complexity saver. Here’s a post that explains it all, but basically, you’re cutting through the backbone so that the turkey can lay flat, allowing it to cook quickly and evenly. Jackpot! I know this doesn’t allow for the beautiful presentation of the whole bird, but I think it’s worth it, for the crispy skin and the even cooking. And all the extremely obvious jokes.

9. Double the mashed potatoes. Trust me.

10. Supply leftover containers. This is a serious sacrifice, I know, and there is a tendency to want to hoard all the delicious leftovers, but really: you can’t eat as many as you think, and it is such a lovely touch to have to-go containers at the ready, so that everyone can pack up the perfect leftover meal.

What are some of your favorite Thanksgiving tips, tricks and recipes?

What advice would you give to someone who’s hosting Thanksgiving, possibly for the first time?




By Posted in - General on November 11th, 2014 26 Comments


You know, of course, that I’m trying to learn a new rhythm of living, that I’ve been inching my way into it for two years, that I’m writing a book about that fumbling process.

Let …

Read More →

Pumpkin Curry

By Posted in - General on October 21st, 2014 13 Comments IMG_5288


Oh, heavens, how long has it been since I’ve posted a recipe? I’ve been working on lots of new recipes, but they’re mostly for Savor–it has more than 20 recipes in it. And the …

Read More →

Using Technology to Connect

By Posted in - General on October 13th, 2014 19 Comments

As I’ve said before, I’m so not anti-technology—I love Instagram, & so much of my job involves the lovely wild odd world of the internet. At the same time, I’ve been having lots of conversations lately …

Read More →

SIMPLIFY Giveaway Winners!

By Posted in - General on August 21st, 2014 4 Comments

Congratulations to these twenty lucky people! The publishing team will send you an email soon to get your mailing address & then your book will be on its way…

1. Nancy Smith
2. Rhonda Roberts
3. Maggie Broderick
4. …

Read More →


By Posted in - General on May 20th, 2014 45 Comments

I just loaded up more than twenty bags and boxes for a garage sale this weekend—not mine, of course, because of all the things in the world I’m terrible at, running a garage sale …

Read More →

On Finding Your Passion

By Posted in - General on May 13th, 2014 29 Comments

Lately I’ve been speaking quite often on the topics of calling and passion, specifically as those topics relate to marriage and parenting and family—what it looks like to build space into a marriage and a …

Read More →

Mother’s Day video

By Posted in - Family on May 11th, 2014 3 Comments

Happy, happy, happy Mother’s Day! My very talented brother-in-law Eric made this short film to honor moms and all the women who nurture and influence and shape us. Isn’t it beautiful?

It’s been a full-to-bursting weekend …

Read More →

A Mother’s Day Book List

By Posted in - General on May 7th, 2014 40 Comments

Mother’s Day always makes me think of books—maybe because of all the things that are so very different about my mother and I, one way we’re absolutely one thousand percent the same is that …

Read More →

On Laundry & Love Stories

By Posted in - General on April 29th, 2014 38 Comments

If I have learned anything at all this year, it’s that marriages never get better on accident, and they never get better on leftovers.

I chatted with a new friend in Nashville last week. She …

Read More →

On Vulnerability & Cats

By Posted in - General on April 16th, 2014 32 Comments

So I asked Twitter & Facebook friends for a blog topic that was non-boring, and the very first response was VULNERABILITY.

Done. Everyone, it seems, is talking about vulnerability right now, which is fantastic. I credit …

Read More →

Why I Love Thursday Nights

By Posted in - General on March 19th, 2014 46 Comments


You know I believe friendship is God’s greatest evidence of himself here on earth.  You know I believe everyone needs a home team: a go-to, show-up, middle of the night, come-in-without-knocking tribe …

Read More →